So, I saw this post on Facebook the other day and it really intrigued me. All these choices are really, really hard. I long to be in a lot of these fictional realms, and I initially didn’t know what to pick. As such, I decided to analyse each scenario here.
Red Button – You get to spend a year at Hogwarts but you’re not magical
This one on the surface seems a very good deal. I mean, you still get to go to Hogwarts no matter what. However, isn’t the whole point to be magical? It’s the school of witchcraft and wizardry. You couldn’t participate in lessons, would certainly get ridiculed by the Slytherins and, if it were me, become depressed and even resentful towards magic. Plus, if these years in Hogwarts are during the timeline of the books, you would be at a major disadvantage. Imagine having no magic during the battle of Hogwarts. You’d be dead within the first hour, surely. So no, I don’t think this is the choice for me.
Orange Button – You’re the Doctor’s companion but you don’t remember your adventures
So… basically you become Donna Noble?
This wouldn’t be such a bad option. I mean, look at all the adventures they went on together. I guess it wouldn’t be worth it if you didn’t remember it all, but it’s the experiences that count. And wouldn’t it hurt the Doctor more? He’d still remember you and all the fun/tears/near-death-experiences you shared together. As ever the Doctor must move on, but I’ve always noticed he’s really sad when he looses his companion.
Especially Rose Tyler
What, who said that…?
Yellow Button – Your favourite character falls in love with you but you can’t have a physical relationship
This would mean I could have a choice of Captain Hook (Once Upon a Time), Loki (Marvel’s Thor) – but happy pre-Thor Loki, not the megalomaniac one in Avengers – Kili (The Hobbit) or Dean Winchester (Supernatural), spend time with them, have a relationship with them, do everything with them but I couldn’t have sex with them? This sounds like the best idea so far! Sex isn’t what makes a relationship, after all. They would still be there to live with, to laugh with, the cuddle with – cuddles aren’t sex, so it still counts – and I could be intimate with them on every other level except the physical ones. People survive everyday, single or in a relationship, without sex, so I think I could too.
I don’t see a downside here.
Green Button – You become a Shadowhunter but will die at the age of 25
Hum.. This is tempting, as out of all the fandoms mentions thus far this is my main one. If someone asked me for my top three fandoms, I would say I was a Shadowhunter first. And since Shadowhunters are trained from birth, I would have had 25 years worth of Shadowhunter experiences. But the thing is, would I know I was going to die at 25? If I did I wouldn’t want it. That would be a horrible feeling, and one of impending doom all the time, weighing down on you… No, if I didn’t know I was going to die that would be better. Being a Shadowhunter is a thankless task but it is one that is needed, and I think it would give me a sense of being in the world. Plus, if I could be at the New York Institute during The Mortal Instruments or the London Institute during The Infernal Devices then life would never be dull.
Blue Button – You’re a demigod but your godly parent never claims you
You see, this is also very temping. Whilst I would feel a little miffed at being abandoned, I would get to spend all of my time in the Hermes Cabin with the Stoll Twins. Imagine how much fun that would be. Plus, I would still have the experience of being a demigod at Camp Half-Blood every summer – or would I be an all year camper? – so I don’t see a downside to this. I would still know that pegasi and satyrs are real, I would get to play capture the flag and sing around the camp-fire, and, while monsters would be trying to kill me, I would be a kick-ass Greek warrior very capable of defending myself. Plus, many other demigods survived without being claimed before the bill that Percy made Zeus pass as his reward for saving the planet. Again.
Purple Button – Sherlock falls in love with you but you can never say you love him back
To be honest, I don’t think that Sherlock is the kind of person who would say it very often himself. He is a sociopath, after all. I think ‘saying’ the words would be such a big thing in his relationships. If he did say it surely it would be to get something out of you, or an act like his brief relationship with Janine. With him, I think there wouldn’t be huge signs of affection, so as much as I would love to be able to say it to him, I think I could live around it.
However, as much as I love Sherlock as a character, I don’t think I could be in a relationship with him. I think I would give into the urge to strangle him far too often. Unless he liked that sort of thing… :p
Pink Button – You become Divergent but you take Tris’s place in the death serum room
Well, after quickly reminding myself as to what the death serum actually is – it’s been a while since I’ve read the book, don’t judge me – it seems that it has something to do with the ending of Allegiant, which I unfortunately haven’t read yet. As I gather, strong Divergent can resist it, as Tris does, so I would hope that I too were strong enough to, also. But, since I don’t know that much about it, I’m not going to press this button, just in case.
Brown Button – You can save Finnick’s life but you have to kill Peeta instead
Ouch. I don’t know if I could cope. I mean, I loved Finnik and hated it when he died (you can click here to read more about that), but then again how can anyone with a soul kill Peeta? Plus, wouldn’t Finnik hate himself and then hate you if he found out that you killed Peeta to save him? Wouldn’t Katnis have an(other) emotional breakdown? No, I don’t think I could do it; this is not the button for me.
Decision
This is so hard! After that discussion, I would say… the yellow button! I could totally live without sex for any of my favourite male characters. Or, if I decided on one of my favourite female characters, sex wouldn’t come into it anyway and I’d just get an amazing and inspirational friend. (But let’s be honest, I’d probably pick a guy). After all, I like to feed my inner romantic and fantasise about a loving but innocent relationship. Aw!
What about you guys? What button would you press? Let me know in the comments!